Thankless Giving

Nov 19, 2026

In this week’s Written & Read, Amanda reflects on the meaning of giving without expecting anything in return, especially when the response isn’t gratitude, but criticism or misunderstanding.

With Thanksgiving just around the corner, I’ve been thinking a lot about gratitude. Not just the gratitude we express when someone does something kind for us, but the gratitude we sometimes hope to receive when we put something of ourselves out into the world.

I’ve always considered the expression of gratitude one of my core values. I believe in acknowledging people, saying thank you, and making sure others know when something they’ve done has mattered.

Lately, I’ve been thinking about what happens when we give without receiving that acknowledgment. And perhaps more importantly, what happens when the response isn’t gratitude at all.

Most every week, I write this column and share it with you and with our community. Nobody asked me to do this. There’s no obligation, no assignment, and certainly no guarantee that anyone will read it. I do it because I want to be additive to this community. I want to offer another perspective to consider, add a little light in a world that seems so overwhelmed with darkness, and authentically express who I am through the talents and gifts I’ve been given. Writing is one of them.

When I was active on social media, sharing these pieces came with a certain amount of feedback. People would comment, share, or send a kind message. I’d see evidence that someone had read something I’d written and perhaps thought about it a little differently. And I’ll be honest. I enjoyed that. Who wouldn’t?

When I stepped away from social media, that applause largely disappeared.

I still receive the occasional email from a subscriber or a comment from someone who took the time to read. Those moments are lovely, and I appreciate every one of them. But I had to make a decision: Was I writing because I wanted the response, or was I writing because I believed there was value in putting these thoughts out into the world?

If it was the latter, then I needed to keep writing whether the applause came or not.

That was an important adjustment for me. I began to understand that the value of something I give isn’t necessarily reflected in the number of people who acknowledge receiving it.

Then came a moment that tested that understanding in a different way.

Recently, I wrote a piece paying tribute to a member of our community who had passed away. My intention was to honor that person and reflect on what their presence meant. The response from one reader was a very critical remark accusing me of using the opportunity to promote myself and suggesting I should keep my thoughts to myself.

I wasn’t expecting that. Especially not on a piece written in tribute to someone who had meant something to our community.

I didn’t respond with a defense of my intentions. I didn’t try to explain myself or convince this person that they’d misunderstood me. I simply let the comment stand.

But it made me pause.

I found myself thinking about how something offered with what I believed were good intentions could be received so differently. And I realized something that I don’t particularly like, but am learning to accept: I cannot control how another person interprets my words or actions. I can be thoughtful. I can try to do no harm. I can make an effort to understand the people around me and consider the impact of what I put into the world. But I cannot guarantee that someone won’t misunderstand me, disagree with me, or assign an intention to my actions that was never there.

People experience the world through their own histories, expectations, disappointments, and beliefs. We don’t all see the same thing when we look at the same situation.

For a long time, I think I believed that if I stayed aligned with my values and made a genuine effort to do right by others, I could avoid conflict. That if my intentions were good, the outcome would be understood as good.

Apparently, that’s not how it works.

And that’s where something Suzanne McAvoy Hopgood said during this week’s North of Normal conversation came back to me.

Suzanne was talking about a period when she’d been unwell and was spending time in Chiang Mai, Thailand. She mentioned some Buddhist sayings that had been helpful to her during this stage of life. One of them was:

“Take the time to decide who you are, without the applause.”

I actually stopped her and asked her to say it again.

Take the time to decide who you are, without the applause.

I’ve thought about those words quite a bit since our conversation. The applause isn’t always literal. Sometimes it’s the thank-you, the positive comment, the recognition, the reassurance that what we’ve done has been received in the way we intended. It’s the feeling that someone sees us, understands us, and appreciates what we’ve offered.

And sometimes, instead of applause, we get silence. Or worse, criticism. A response that makes us question why we bothered in the first place.

What do we do then?

There are a lot of people in our community who are doing good things, often quietly and without much recognition. People who are brave enough to share their ideas, give their time, create something, stand up for something they believe in, and offer their talents in service to others. People who are putting themselves out there because they feel called to contribute something meaningful.

And some of them are being criticized, judged, misunderstood, or disregarded along the way.

I wonder how many good things never make it into the world because someone decided the possibility of criticism wasn’t worth the risk. How many of us stop sharing, stop volunteering, stop creating, or stop showing up because the response wasn’t what we hoped it would be?

I’m not suggesting we ignore criticism. Sometimes it’s warranted. Sometimes someone sees something in us that we haven’t been willing to see in ourselves. We can choose to remain curious enough to listen, consider another perspective, and acknowledge when we’ve gotten something wrong.

But there’s a difference between being willing to learn from criticism and allowing it to define us.

And there’s a difference between appreciating gratitude and needing it in order to keep giving.

I don’t think I’ll ever stop appreciating a sincere thank-you. I hope I never do. But I’m beginning to understand that I don’t need one every time I offer something of myself. The same is true of recognition, approval, and agreement. They are wonderful when they come, but they cannot be the reason we do everything.

Maybe that’s what thankless giving is really about. Not giving until we’re empty, accepting poor treatment, or pretending that appreciation doesn’t matter. It’s about being able to separate the intention behind what we give from the reaction we receive.

And as we head into Thanksgiving, I have one more thought I’d like to leave with you.

What if, before we sit down at our tables and reflect on all the things we’re grateful for, we take a moment to examine some of the judgments we hold about the people in our community?

The person whose approach we don’t understand. The person whose words rubbed us the wrong way. The person who does things differently than we would. The person we’ve quietly dismissed without taking the time to understand what motivates them.

What if we looked again? What if we found even one small thing about that person to appreciate, something we might have overlooked because we were too busy deciding what we didn’t like?

Perhaps we could offer a little gratitude where we’ve previously offered judgment.

Wouldn’t that be a true Thanks Giving?

author avatar
Amanda McKeen Creator
Amanda McKeen is the host of the North of Normal Podcast, founder of Clear View Advantage, and creator of White Mountains Directory, bringing people and communities together with a shared vision of a North Country where everyone has the opportunity to live with greater abundance, joy, and love.

6 Comments

  1. Don Hadden

    I’m so happy Amanda that you’re not letting the occasional criticism get you down, or worse, silence you. As a wise old song goes; “Well it’s alright now. Learned my lesson well. You can’t please everyone, so you’ve got to please yourself”.

    You’re pleasing far more people than you realize, so please continue to share your gift of wisdom and eloquent writing with us! Happy Thanksgiving.

    Reply
    • Amanda McKeen

      A very Happy Thanksgiving to you, Don. Thank you for your understanding, support, and wonderful words of encouragement. All gifts fully received!🙏💜

      Reply
  2. Adhi Two Owls

    There is an interesting dynamic between our personal understanding of who we are and how the world sees us. It’s not always the same. These social platforms that come between us as the acceptable form of communication these days can often be the root of profound misunderstanding.

    In my own journey, I have found the practice for being just “me” in the world is to be authentic and not be attached to the results. It took a long time to get there. I had to take some deep inner inventory and find the willingness to evolve away from misunderstandings of who I thought I was. That is the journey we all take. I think kindness is important. We don’t know the inner struggles of others. We live in a society today that conflates strength with bullying, while at the same time dismissing vulnerability and compassion as weakness. This makes the path of authenticity seeded with mines and deterrents.

    Regardless of that, the world is always moving in a better direction when we are true to who we are and live kindly.

    Reply
    • Amanda McKeen

      Adhi, thank you for this valuable input. I have always appreciated how you communicate your truth, and am so honored you took the time to do it here. I could not possibly agree more with what you’ve shared. And I know from our chats that you really know from experience these inner understandings. Thanks for being Who You Are and living kindly.

      Reply
  3. Lynne Grigelevich

    I will never regret growing older because of the incredible life lessons that contribute to my ever-growing peace. I appreciate this reflection, and I love Adhi Two Owls’ response as well. Detachment is a very powerful life skill – I also refer to it as no expectations. Now imagine that: living without expectations. When I speak to others of this, almost all say it is impossible. How can you not expect…from your partner, your colleague, your friend, etc…? It takes WORK and is one of the biggest muscles you can strengthen. You get almost daily practice. Haha! But when you can lean into it, wow, what a gamechanger.

    I don’t mean accepting what is not good for you. Not at all. If you recognize a person or a situation is not good for you, then you next choice is determined by whether you try to remedy it or walk away. Detachment means their response/actions/words do not determine how you feel. Move through the world with kindness, generosity, and compassion, and simply observe how others choose to move through the world. Sometimes, what you “receive” will fill your heart, and that is a gift. Other times, not…but it also won’t hurt your heart or your confidence or your knowing who you are and what your intentions are.

    Kudos to you for taking that comment, recognizing it was not you but wherever she was in that moment, not judging her for it, and responding the way you did – with kindness. And then writing this wonderful reflection – tagged on to Suzanne’s incredibly wise words of wisdom. Thanks, Amanda. <3

    Reply
    • Amanda McKeen

      YES, Lynne!!! Doesn’t this just make you smile from ear to ear? Our very first Reiki session you told me… “Learn to give without expecting anything in return.” Thank you for being a light and moving through the world with kindness, compassion, and gratitude. We’re so very lucky to be here right now. Thank you for reading and sharing your wisdom. ☺️💜

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *